Frame for Who Is More Responsible for Eva’s Death, Sheila or Arthur Birling?

You need to

1 put the information into sentences 2 find supporting quotations

Note. Some quotations are partially done for you. Scan the text to complete them.

Intro: explain that a girl called Eva has just killed herself, and Goole has revealed a ‘chain of events’

1st para on Sheila

Sheila is Arthur Birling's daughter. She may be compared to him:

2nd para

However, there are many contrasts:

Sheila reacts sympathetically to the news of Eva's suicide ('Oh- how ..........'), whereas Arthur is dismissive ('Yes, yes. Horrid...........')

S wants to hear more ('Was it.. ..................?') but A wants to get on with the party.

Her character is therefore a ..................... one. (Find an appropriate adjective.)

Sheila’s intuitive judgement is usually right, as when she works out …………..

Arthur’s judgement is usually wrong, as when he speaks about…………….(Titanic, war) and when he states his view that every man should look after himself (find this – near the start, just before Goole arrives).

Who judges she IS involved in Evs’s death, and who claims he is not?

3rd para

Attitude to Goole when he is interrogating them

However, her father on the other hand is ...........................(contrast each one)

4th para

After Goole leaves, Sheila's attitude is (find the quotations)

Her father's attitude is

Sheila responds to this with sarcasm ('I suppose we're all ...........people now')

5th para

Priestley uses dramatic devices to reveal character.

6th para

In conclusion, although they all helped to kill her, S is more responsible for her death than Birling because he arguably had a legitimate reason for sacking her, whereas she acted out of ............ and spite. Her concern about her appearance and status - (say where YOU think it comes from). S is however forgiving to .............. who has been disloyal, whereas her father was unforgiving to ......... and started the chain of.............. which led to......................