Poem

Surface Meaning

Subtle Meaning

Style

Example of Response

Blessing

Description of the activity when a water pipe bursts

the word' frantic' in l17 hints that the burst will lead to a cut-off;

the refs to 'God' l6, 'congregation' and 'blessing' l22suggest the religious status of water;

v4 reminds us that water baptises children with the forgiveness of God's son (note the pun sun/son)

Implicit contrast with western culture, where water is plentiful.

Verses and rhythm add to the meaning.

v1 sets the scene;

v2 stresses the value of water;

v3 is long with long sentences, suggesting the rush of the mains water. Note the vivid simile in l1 'like a pod' , the metaphor 'silver' in l9 to suggest the value of water, the alliteration in l20 (p.....) to remind us children are perfect, made in god's image.

I realise that water is a blessing, just like God's blessing. It is appropriate that water - gift of life –is used in the ceremony of baptism.The poem begins in the material world (basics of life) and ends in the spiritual.

Water is also precious in another sense – valuable in climates where it is rare.

Presents from My Aunts...

NB poem in

Cluster 2- a bonus poem for you

The poet received clothes from Pakistan which she did not feel at home in and reflects on why.

As an immigrant, she's caught between two cultures;

1. she's half English;

2. she wants other things, not clothes - things separate from her

3. her schoolfriend is not impressed

4 she is an immigrant, 'of no fixed nationality' and thinks of the journey away from Pakistan.

Free verse -as if thinking aloud;

confessional ;

uses 'I' - written in 1st person;

broken lines suggest thoughts;

l24 effective metaphor;

strong colours and visual images;

accessible vocabulary.

Makes me think about having roots in one culture and living in another. It is natural to want to fit in but you can still have an interest (eg newspapers, photos, things) in your origins.

Limbo

Description of a limbo dancer going down under the bar and then surfacing, to rhythmical accompaniment, on the other side

1 the dance is a metaphor for the voyage of slaves across the Atlantic –they descend into ship’s holds before surfacing on foreign soil;

2 more subtly, the poem is a metaphor for the oppression of black Americansand their eventual freeing from slavery and emancipation.

1 strong incnatatory rhythm suggests dance;

2 pattern of limbo/limbo like me looks like waves;

3 incremental repetition (20-23) suggests the horror of the captives’ realisation of their fate;

4 strong visual symbolism of dark vs sun

I realise the ordeal and challenge of a limbo dance as well as the real horrors of the slave voyages and the centuries of oppression.

Nothing’s Changed

The narrator picks his way through the Cape Town shrubland that was once District 6.

Segregation by colour (apartheid) has been replaced with segregation by wallet – and most of the poor are black.

1 concentration of hard, monosyllabic words gives an unwelcome tone;

2 the ‘amiable weeds’ are native and belong but are unwanted: they symbolise the poor and black;

3. the ‘Port Jackson trees’ are imported and valued, like the white settlers;

4. the glass window symbolises the now invisible barrier which has replaced apartheid.

The poem makes me realise that economic equality will take a long time to achieve in South Africa; it cannot, like political equality –one man one vote- happen overnight.

Island Man

A Caribbean island man wakes up in London

The man still carries his memory and culture in his mind, so that his semi-awake brain confuses traffic noise for the ‘sound of blue surf’ and the creases of his pillow for ‘waves’.

The environments of the Caribbean island and London are contrasted in terms of both sound and colour (eg emerald/grey metallic or seabirds/roar);

‘Morning’ suggests a pun on ‘mourning’ – the man misses his island;

Sense of not wanting to get up in such an environment – he ‘heaves himself’ up;

Position of ‘groggily groggily’ suggests the struggle to wake up.

The contrast sounds almost like the city vs nature. Perhaps the man’s situation resembles Everyman: we all share a ‘golden age’ nostalgia for a more natural life, away from the artificiality of civilisation.

Vultures

The poet reflects on the apparently affectionate pair-bonding of a bird which scavenges and feeds on dead animals.

Evil can be found within good as good is found within evil.

A concentration camp commandant may be a good loving father to his own children despite spending the day as a murderer.

This co-existence of good-with-evil and evil-with-good may offer hope or despair.

1 The mood of the poem is a bleak one: even the ‘dawn’ –normally a symbol of hope- is here ‘despondent’ and marked not by sunrise (hope) but ‘drizzle’ (note the alliteration);

2 the four stanzas in blank verse move from the particular to the general, from the observed to the philosophical;

3 note the cumulative force of the negative lexis (choice of words).

The contrast here is within one man with the eg of the Commandant. There is a comparison between man and the world of nature: good and evil are found in both. The poem’s conclusion is certainly thought-provoking.

Now that I have got you started, have a go at completing this grid so that you have brief notes on ALL the Cluster 1 poems. You could very usefully add a column for the poems that each could be compared with.

 

 

 

 

Helpsheet for pupils at Bournemouth School by I. Curr 2006